The Removal Of The Sexism Pisses Me Off Not Because It Just Affects Sokkas Character But Because It Has

The removal of the sexism pisses me off not because it just affects Sokkas character but because it has ruined almost every woman in the show.

Suki takes off her make up often, as if it isn't a large part of her cultural identity and personality, as if her being a kyoshi warior and her destinctly femenine clothes are something to be ashamed off or that hinders her. Because its only her that gets this treat amongst the warriors, and shes the only main kyoshi warrior for the audience.

Yue's entire character is removed. It is replaced with what I think is meant to be a sympathetic princess to the people, she joins the nans in the kitchens and make deserts for the children. Like a disney princess whose quirky and silly and held back only by her title of a princess. Gone is the battle between her desire to help and her duty to be a water tribe ideal woman. Gone is her realising that the best way to help her people is to not be an ideal woman, but to take action and to do what no one else can, to become one with the moon so that she can forever help not just her tribe but the entire world. It is depressing, it is deep, it isn't fair to her but when has the world ever been fair?

Katara aswell. Her bending is forever unlocked by men (Aang and Jet), her defiance of authority is lessened and her naievety is also changed. A lot of her motherhood role is also completlty gone since they have changed Sokkas sexism into elder brother smothering. Her fight with Paku holds a lot less significance since she has no RAGE behind her. No rage that has built for YEARS as time and time again people have said no to her face for being a woman, for being weak, for not being enough simply because of who she is. that doesn't exist for her anymore because the water tribes are just...nice. We see one bad person in the water tribe and its Hadoka and he's mean to sokka! Kataras rage comes from Paku saying no to her, and whilst thats swell, it changes her entire "I'm a master now" moment into just...lame girlbossery. Thats kinda how the entire last 2 episodes felt like for her character. A common girlboss character without the emotional depth to make it femenism.

I think my main issue is that both shows set themselves up as being femenist by nature. The og show wanted to tackle issues with sexism, using book 1 as its main demonstration with it, but the theme still follows throughout the narative. netflix's show outright said they were removing the sexist elements. When you place youself onto that pedastal, any sexist writing you have becomes emphasised.

The og show undoubtably has sexist moments! Irohs comments to June are the most obvious to me, a long with a couple comments from Zuko later on. You can certainly argue that the extreme lack of GOOD mother figures is an issue (Kat and Sokkas mother is dead, Zukos is 'dead', and Toph is awful and rather quite compared to her father). Theres other examples, although currently my brain cannot think of any since I don't often write indepth critisms.

The live actions main point of sexism is its female main characters. we literally meet Yue in the kitchen! Women can be in kitchens but that is certainly a choice! Theres this strange hatred for make up aswell, yes with Suki but also with Sokka. His war paint is removed. Its like saying make up cannot be worn by strong fighters which is rather sexist. Speaking off: not putting Sokka in the kyoshi outfit is just...dumb? If you want to show him learning the style, having him wear the outfit. Its an aspect of the style and philosophy. A man wearing make up and a skirt doesn't emasculate him yet the show makes it feel that way with the refusal to do it. "Oh but then you'd have Sokka and Suki kiss in the kyoshi outfits" who cares. "it will look like lesbians" it won't. Even if it did, who cares? you can't be 'femenist' and anti-lesbian. Putting Sokka in the Kyoshi outfit, having him respect it, is just as important as having Aang learn the other elements, or Iroh creating lightning redirection. Why? because it shows a respect of culture, and how you can blend that into your own way of thinking. It's cultural extchanged based on respect.

When you name yourself femenist, yet have explicitly sexist writing, your GOING to get dogpiled with critism based on that 'femenist' msg.

More Posts from Sora-of-uranus and Others

3 months ago

I both love and hate Oedipus Rex because the end is so stupid.

The whole play is (in one interpretation!) about self-identity and the battle between knowing who we are and how we are percieved by ourselves and the world around us. You'd expect for Oedipus to end the play fully relalized and yet...

By blinding himself, which, yes it is out of guilt and is a form of self-flagellation, but it also acts as a way to continue ignoring who he is. Without eyes he cannot see his children, the genetic abominations, nor does he have to see the world he has helped corrupt. He can continue to live in bliss. In his blindness he does not become Tiresias- he is not a prophet- he is just a pathetic man as scared as us to see himself in the mirror.


Tags
3 years ago

Kuina is probably very pro-turtles and I feel like to piss her off Last boss will ONLY use plastic straws. And I mean only. drinking dr pepper? straw. drinking water? straw drinking black coffee? straw eating soup? straw spaghetti? straw  this man has most definitely eaten an entire 3 course meal with a plastic straw to spite Kuina and she just couldn't react other than crying because wtf is this dumbass doing


Tags
1 year ago

I love how they gloss over Spencer getting Anthrax poisining so quickly. I mean they do this for ALL traumas but I feel like they should've at least shown him struggling to breath whilst running for the next few cases, maybe some people being double worried to let spencer go into crime scene alone, and of course spencer holding this against them. I need them to go "spencer I don't think-" "Who was it that helped solve a case whilst DYING of Anthrax??? cuss last I checked you wern't the one laying with a breathing tube up his nose for a week. So anyway this 6th cup of coffee is super needed at 11am"


Tags
3 years ago

In a fairy tail here's the roles of characters. yeah. woo.  Kuina is the pretty Princes who fucking wrecks her captures ass  Usagi is the other pretty princes who comes to save Kuina by offering her a horse as a getaway car  chishiya is the horse  Arisu is her butler  Hatter is a random bird that the villain owns and screams the future but its really lame things like “mark from down the street will have waffles on Thursday at 3am whilst watching titanic”.  He also only speaks in French  Aguni is like the villains cat that is always arguing with the bird/hatter except he only speaks Polish  Last boss is the story teller who's like narrating it all and is sat on a bean bag with a pop up book in his lap as a bunch of kids stare at him scared 


Tags
3 years ago

omfg that's genius I love it 

Alice in borderland au where everything’s the same but hatter is animated like a cartoon

6 months ago
Sokka Painting Kya And Zuko Is There (yes This Is Posted On TikTok Too) (OH MY GOD IM GENUINELY CONFUSED

Sokka painting Kya and Zuko is there (yes this is posted on TikTok too) (OH MY GOD IM GENUINELY CONFUSED HOW TUMBLR WORKS THAT WHY IM NOT ON IT MUCH)

10 months ago

The way that I understood it was that supernatural creatures like Seers or witches/mages where encoded into their DNA. Like no matter what Ethan and Benny did there was no way to never NOT become these supernatural creatures (even if they did have special moments to 'unlock' this ability. Although for me it feels more akin to learning to run rather than magical girl transformation type unlocking but thats boring). On the otherhand things like vampirism or lycanthropy are similar to a disease but just....amplified. and so the miracle cure would then work as an almost super antibody rather than a purification of anything supernatural. It's a vacine not holy water ya feel? Although this view is also SOOO borring and basic so ya know ignore me.

Okay so Ethan drank the Supernatural all cure and he was still a seer after, I feel like this tells us something but I can't quite articulate what right now


Tags
3 years ago

My one thing I want in life is a deep 50k word social media mutuals who sometiems talk, to accidental pannel hosters together, to friends, to sorta awkward frenemies back to friends, to lovers Aguni/Hatter fic set as them like cosplayers. Aguni does more like video game cosplays and Hatter does more action movie/ cool tv show cosplays and shit.  Oh and also like sleep. Sleep would be nice aswell   


Tags
7 months ago

You know I do think it's interesting how strongly Fullmetal Alchemist (2003) makes the point that bringing someone back from the dead is inherently selfish.

I've seen it elsewhere but not nearly as unequivocally and plainly put. First, we have Majhal in episode 4 - an alchemist so obsessed with bringing back his dead love, he completely fails to notice that she survived and returned to him. And even once the truth is revealed... he rejects her, since she's not the ~perfect girl~ from his memories, but an old woman - an actual person, with an actual life.

And if you missed it there, we then meet Tucker, so obsessed with keeping his lifestyle and success as a State Alchemist he does, you know, that. And then he goes on to become obsessed with bringing her back - but not her, not really, as he straight-up tells Ed in the 5th laboratory - he wants the girl from his memories, the perfect, unchanging doll.

Both times, we see that those obsessed with bringing someone back from the dead aren't interested in bringing back a person, with thoughts and feelings and their own independent life to live - no, they want their idea of that person, the glowing angel who could never change, never grow, and never go wrong. And that also goes for Ed and Izumi too - Ed was so obsessed with bringing his mother back that he ignored Pinako, ignored the family that took him in, and selfishly put his brother's life at risk... for which he paid the price. Izumi lost her ability to have future children, any of them, stuck on a dream on the child she could have had. Both didn't want that mother/child - they wanted their loved ones, the ones they dreamed of, not the ones that were actually there.

Most times resurrection is brought up in media, it's with the lesson that "oh, the cost is too high", "oh, you're disturbing their rest", "oh, they don't come back right." It's rare to see it put so clearly, so obviously, so horrifically that actually, no, even the fact that you attempt it - even the fact that you want to - is an inherently selfish act, that turns your back on life and the living to chase a dream that may not have ever existed.

It's an interesting take on the whole idea, of death and life and memory and obsession. For all that 2003 dropped the ball on the ending, I do love the development they gave to the characters!

Loading...
End of content
No more pages to load
  • obeymearmageddonau
    obeymearmageddonau liked this · 2 months ago
  • myssticks
    myssticks liked this · 2 months ago
  • manilovescp166
    manilovescp166 liked this · 5 months ago
  • sugarblast
    sugarblast liked this · 8 months ago
  • anime-pencil-drawings
    anime-pencil-drawings liked this · 1 year ago
  • waitwhatisaname
    waitwhatisaname liked this · 1 year ago
  • chocolatechipcheesecake
    chocolatechipcheesecake liked this · 1 year ago
  • tibea
    tibea liked this · 1 year ago
  • soulslapper2000
    soulslapper2000 liked this · 1 year ago
  • carnistcervine
    carnistcervine liked this · 1 year ago
  • aclusterfuckoffandomandinsomnia
    aclusterfuckoffandomandinsomnia liked this · 1 year ago
  • demonfairyprincess
    demonfairyprincess liked this · 1 year ago
  • jackassrabbit
    jackassrabbit liked this · 1 year ago
  • plumedesnuages
    plumedesnuages reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • nuage-de-plumes
    nuage-de-plumes liked this · 1 year ago
  • goldenairraven
    goldenairraven liked this · 1 year ago
  • fruitty-lil-bat
    fruitty-lil-bat liked this · 1 year ago
  • cool-ttgaming-love
    cool-ttgaming-love liked this · 1 year ago
  • singingdancingswan
    singingdancingswan liked this · 1 year ago
  • mycatisblued
    mycatisblued liked this · 1 year ago
  • eatmyshoe
    eatmyshoe liked this · 1 year ago
  • miss-sunshines-blog
    miss-sunshines-blog reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • miss-sunshines-blog
    miss-sunshines-blog liked this · 1 year ago
  • dreadclown
    dreadclown liked this · 1 year ago
  • the-falling-avenger
    the-falling-avenger liked this · 1 year ago
  • natashastark27
    natashastark27 liked this · 1 year ago
  • jennybobenny73
    jennybobenny73 liked this · 1 year ago
  • antoniat12
    antoniat12 liked this · 1 year ago
  • jevilowo
    jevilowo reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • jevilowo
    jevilowo liked this · 1 year ago
  • eloquentgifs
    eloquentgifs reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • analviel
    analviel liked this · 1 year ago
  • blackmoonlight1
    blackmoonlight1 liked this · 1 year ago
  • bislutcowboy
    bislutcowboy liked this · 1 year ago
  • anxiousapathy23
    anxiousapathy23 liked this · 1 year ago
  • jp9639
    jp9639 liked this · 1 year ago
  • lesabear
    lesabear reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • velracxx
    velracxx reblogged this · 1 year ago
  • velracxx
    velracxx liked this · 1 year ago
  • littleweowmeow
    littleweowmeow liked this · 1 year ago
  • og-fanofmyself
    og-fanofmyself liked this · 1 year ago
  • celestialstardustseeker
    celestialstardustseeker liked this · 1 year ago

character names are meant to be spelt wrong ok. They/them

235 posts

Explore Tumblr Blog
Search Through Tumblr Tags